• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Subscribe
  • Twitter
  • RSS Feed

Investment News NZ

Investment News provides financial advisers news stories from the financial industry in New Zealand. Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter.

  • Home
  • News
  • Kiwisaver
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Investment News / Benchmark blues: why the index offers guaranteed disappointment

Benchmark blues: why the index offers guaranteed disappointment

October 13, 2019

Steffan Berridge: Kiwi Invest senior investment strategist

Passive fund investors will be “disappointed in the long run”, according to a just-released Kiwi Invest analysis.

The paper published by the investment arm of the government-owned Kiwi Wealth business argues that passive funds have built a “false economy” on the back of self-interested index managers and benchmark suppliers.

“We believe that the research behind the headlines is inadequate and highly biased, and a poor source of advice for investors – but a frequent darling of the press, due to its headline-grabbing sense of disruption,” the report says.

Authored by Kiwi Invest senior investment strategist, Steffan Berridge, the paper aims to debunk some common ‘myths’ about active and passive styles covering performance, theoretical underpinnings and definitions.

Berridge says commonly-stated statistics showing most active managers underperform benchmarks after fees can be misleading while the equivalent result for index funds is usually overlooked.

“At first glance, this statement looks bad for all active managers, but considering the equivalent statement for passive managers, that number goes up to 100% underperformance since they charge fees, albeit small ones, on their benchmark return,” he says.

The paper also questions the reliance on ‘efficient market hypothesis’ – which assumes all assets are fairly-priced – to explain the passive story.

“A closer look at this theory reveals that it’s highly idealistic and contains big holes,” Berridge says in the report. “The main departures from reality are that market participants have any level of agreement on how to calculate fair prices, that they have equal access to information and equal ability to process this information, and the fact investors have both variable benchmarks and variable incentives.”

Finally, he says investors need to distinguish between the wide range of managers lumped under the ‘active’ label. The paper says rather than a marketing label, funds should be measured by ‘active share’, which offers a clearer insight into how managers differ from the underlying benchmark.

Active share, for example, would help investors identify ‘closet indexers’ charging high fees, the report says.

Despite the downsides, index funds have some uses, Berridge says, such as providing “cheap access to liquidity” and efficiently implementing tactical asset allocation. He says passive funds have also helped investors by setting the bottom line on fees.

Under a rule-of-thumb investors can gauge the value of active fees using the cheapest index fund as a baseline, the paper says. A reasonable active fee would equate to the lowest-cost “comparably passively managed fund” plus a third of the “expected pre-fee outperformance” of the more expensive fund and the, more subjective, “value to the investors of additional services”.

But the reference low-cost passive fund fee must include “any underlying manager fees and tax drag which may not be included in the headline fee rates”, the Kiwi Invest analysis says.

Kiwi Invest has about $6 billion under management, sourced mainly through the Kiwi Wealth KiwiSaver scheme. The manager pursues an active management strategy with a large overweight to offshore shares – including exposure to some indices via exchange-traded funds.

Overall, the paper concludes that the passive-vs-active argument is “no longer a real debate”.

“It’s an anachronism of a real debate that’s been resolved over the last 50 years through careful research into making better investment decisions, and a significant reduction in fees across the board,” the report says.

The index-investing world is now driven by “conflicted agents”, Berridge says.

“… the managers of passive products and index providers who are all incentivised to drive flows into their products without necessarily looking to innovate or deliver any additional value to their clients.”

 

 

 

Twitter0
LinkedIn0
Google+0
Facebook0

Read More » Investment News

Recent articles

  • New Salt suite to spice up fund mix January 17, 2021
  • Wealth head quits ASB for Tower job; Platinum loses Asia manager; Matterson moves from Milliman January 17, 2021
  • Westpac follows ANZ with Northern Trust mandate… January 17, 2021
  • … as Trust Management wins over another senior BT investment hand January 17, 2021
  • Capital ventures into BlackRock’s ETF territory January 17, 2021
  • Fresh CIO role as South Pacific aims for co-investments January 17, 2021
  • Lessons from 2020: don’t stop thinking about tomorrow January 17, 2021
  • SSGA to push big firms on ESG, stays mum on merger January 17, 2021
  • Low-carbon switch: why electric future turns on listed infrastructure investor January 17, 2021

Primary Sidebar

WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Sign up here to receive our weekly newsletter.
Learn More »

Most Recent Investment News

New Salt suite to spice up fund mix

January 17, 2021

Wealth head quits ASB for Tower job; Platinum loses Asia manager; Matterson moves from Milliman

January 17, 2021

Westpac follows ANZ with Northern Trust mandate…

January 17, 2021

… as Trust Management wins over another senior BT investment hand

January 17, 2021

Capital ventures into BlackRock’s ETF territory

January 17, 2021

Search by Keyword

Investment News

  • New Salt suite to spice up fund mix January 17, 2021
  • Wealth head quits ASB for Tower job; Platinum loses Asia manager; Matterson moves from Milliman January 17, 2021
  • Westpac follows ANZ with Northern Trust mandate… January 17, 2021
  • … as Trust Management wins over another senior BT investment hand January 17, 2021
  • Capital ventures into BlackRock’s ETF territory January 17, 2021
  • Fresh CIO role as South Pacific aims for co-investments January 17, 2021
  • Lessons from 2020: don’t stop thinking about tomorrow January 17, 2021
  • SSGA to push big firms on ESG, stays mum on merger January 17, 2021
  • Low-carbon switch: why electric future turns on listed infrastructure investor January 17, 2021
  • Bitcoin: the nonsensical asset that makes sense for the times January 17, 2021

Investment News Archive

Most Popular Articles

  • Westpac NZ flags retail advice sale to Forsyth Barr posted on October 19, 2020
  • NZ share-trading splurge could trigger tax alarms… posted on October 5, 2020
  • The horror year in technicolour: free KiwiSaver 13 report released posted on September 30, 2020
  • Flint set to spark platform competition posted on August 17, 2020
  • Four to the core: Smartshares to expand, rearrange and reprice ETFs posted on June 22, 2020
  • Kitset KiwiSaver scheme set to unwrap in spring posted on April 27, 2020
  • Funds eye bargains, self-shoppers hoard cash, KiwiSavers turn conservative posted on March 15, 2020
  • AMP Capital NZ chief quits amid equities exodus offshore posted on August 28, 2020

Sponosored Content

David-Boyle

On the industry play-list: four chart-topping regulations for 2021

David-Boyle

Charge of the lite (advice) brigade

Nathan Field

Pandemic Baby Boom a Bust

Star-date 2020: it’s inflation Jim but not as we know it

Quick-links to Popular News

  • FAP Compliance
  • Coronavirus
  • New Appointments
  • Financial Markets Authority (FMA)
  • Kiwisaver
  • Climate Change
  • Crypto Currency
  • Blockchain
  • Insurance

Secondary Sidebar

Recent News

  • New Salt suite to spice up fund mix January 17, 2021
  • Wealth head quits ASB for Tower job; Platinum loses Asia manager; Matterson moves from Milliman January 17, 2021
  • Westpac follows ANZ with Northern Trust mandate… January 17, 2021
  • … as Trust Management wins over another senior BT investment hand January 17, 2021
  • Capital ventures into BlackRock’s ETF territory January 17, 2021
  • Fresh CIO role as South Pacific aims for co-investments January 17, 2021
  • Lessons from 2020: don’t stop thinking about tomorrow January 17, 2021
  • SSGA to push big firms on ESG, stays mum on merger January 17, 2021
  • Low-carbon switch: why electric future turns on listed infrastructure investor January 17, 2021
  • Bitcoin: the nonsensical asset that makes sense for the times January 17, 2021

Footer

Copyright ©2020 InvestmentNews.co.nz — All Rights Reserved ·— Terms & Conditions