• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Subscribe
  • Twitter
  • RSS Feed

Investment News

  • Home
  • News
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Investment News / Industry ponders final GST moves as endgame approaches

Industry ponders final GST moves as endgame approaches

June 10, 2018

Paul Smith: EY tax partner

NZ fund managers should have one last crack at lobbying the Inland Revenue Department (IRD) on the proposed GST zero-rating for unit trust fees.

According to Paul Smith, head of indirect tax for the NZ arm of global consultancy firm EY, fund managers have a “narrow window” to put their case to the IRD before any final decision on the fraught GST issue.

Smith said the IRD was likely to wrap up the unit trust decision in a broader GST tidy-up paper due at the end of June.

And in a departure from the original intention to provide a public ruling, any GST change for fund fees – or even confirmation of the status quo – would probably be included in the regular end-of-year tax legislation, he said.

“There would be a limited time to consult [on the broad GST paper] before the tax bill has be drafted – which is usually at the end of the calendar year,” Smith said.

If written into any tax legislation, the fund manager GST fee saga, which has dragged on since 2014, would not be resolved until 2019.

Smith said the long “frustrating” consultation process reflected the difficulty the IRD had in marrying the letter of the law with the current de facto industry arrangement for GST on fees.

The IRD recognised that the long-standing industry agreement to allow managers to charge the 15 per cent sales tax on 10 per cent of unit trust fees “had no basis in GST law”.

However, the IRD’s proposed solution of scrapping the industry hand-shake deal in favour of the bog-standard GST zero-rating for ‘financial services’ had produced a few unintended – and unforeseen – consequences.

Most notably, stand-alone fund management firms would lose the right to claim back GST expenses for third-party services – such as administration – that conglomerate firms could transfer in-house.

“The fact some managers would have to pay a 15 per cent tax on outsourced services [with no expense claim-back facility] is a big issue,” Smith said.

He said the IRD relied primarily on information from the Financial Services Council (FSC) – which brokered the original GST deal for the industry – when starting the policy review.

“But a significant number of managers have different business models to the [typically conglomerate] FSC firms,” he said.

While a number of boutique managers previously banded together to lobby the IRD on the point, Smith said enthusiasm was dwindling after the almost four-year long process.

“In 2014 we had about 10 to 12 managers together – now there’s five or so,” he said.

The long-winded review also highlighted a more fundamental issue on the definition of ‘financial services’, which the fund fee decision hinged on.

“Our GST regime dates back to 1985,” Smith said. “Financial services has moved on quite a lot since then.”

Twitter0
LinkedIn0
Google+0
Facebook0

Read More » Investment News

Done reading? Why Not Subscribe? To receive a weekly email with the latest investment news, enter your email address here.

Reader Interactions

Related Articles:

  • Locals fiddled as global industry burned, FMA chief says
  • Best of times over, NZS chair says return to normality inevitable
  • Ex Russell consultant opens independent shop
  • Top managers jump ship from AMP Capital Australia
  • Northern Trust puts some spring in the step of its alternatives

Primary Sidebar

WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Sign up here to receive our weekly newsletter.
Learn More »

More Recent Investment News

EY examines the trend with the ‘new’ alternatives

December 9, 2019

MMC reshuffles management as new CEO climbs aboard

December 2, 2019

NZ-linked private equity pair hover over AMP

December 2, 2019

Transition ignition as 20 plus advice firms file for licence

December 2, 2019

Investment News

  • Fair cop: government sneaks in conduct bill before year-end
  • MMC begins Aegis era with front-end refurbish plans…
  • … as Consilium showcases new-look FNZ wrap
  • Booster mulls master trust option
  • Portfolio manager re-titled at Pie; Mercer fills risk vacancy; BNZ bolsters governance; Sharesies director goes
  • Institutional investors squeeze NZ firms on carbon risk
  • Optimism, jobs on the up in Australasian wealth market
  • Bennelong confirms Janus Henderson EM defectors
  • Study finds lumps in global passive popularity
  • EY examines the trend with the ‘new’ alternatives

Secondary Sidebar

Recent News

  • Fair cop: government sneaks in conduct bill before year-end
  • MMC begins Aegis era with front-end refurbish plans…
  • … as Consilium showcases new-look FNZ wrap
  • Booster mulls master trust option
  • Portfolio manager re-titled at Pie; Mercer fills risk vacancy; BNZ bolsters governance; Sharesies director goes
  • Institutional investors squeeze NZ firms on carbon risk
  • Optimism, jobs on the up in Australasian wealth market
  • Bennelong confirms Janus Henderson EM defectors
  • Study finds lumps in global passive popularity
  • EY examines the trend with the ‘new’ alternatives

Copyright ©2019 InvestmentNews.co.nz — All Rights Reserved ·— Terms & Conditions