• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Subscribe
  • Twitter
  • RSS Feed

Investment News NZ

Investment News provides financial advisers news stories from the financial industry in New Zealand. Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter.

  • Home
  • News
  • Kiwisaver
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Investment News / Passive policing: why index-trackers need regulation

Passive policing: why index-trackers need regulation

February 21, 2021

Adriana Robertson : University of Toronto Associate Professor of Law and Finance

Index providers should face the same regulatory hurdles as investment managers, a new US legal paper argues.

The University of Virginia School of Law (UVS) report says most index providers are de facto ‘investment advisers’ – a term under US law that includes fund managers and multi-manager firms – and should be policed as such.

Currently, index firms, who now hold huge sway over global markets after the swing to passive investing in recent years, remain exempt from investment adviser regulation in the US as merely information ‘publishers’.

But the paper – authored by legal academics Paul Mahoney and Adriana Robertson – says index providers have shifted from offering neutral benchmarks to building a broad range of investable indices based on subjective criteria.

In 2019 passive investments represented the majority of US stock market holdings for the first time. As at the end of that year, US index-based investments hit about US$8.5 trillion, including US$4.4 trillion in exchange-traded funds (ETFs), the analysis says.

“The rise of index funds means that for a multi-trillion-dollar portion of the fund market, the portfolio allocation decisions are made not by the fund’s nominal investment advisor, but rather by an index provider, which is compensated for its efforts through a licensing fee,” the report says. “This is a major development in the fund industry that in many ways parallels the rise of mutual fund sub-advisers [such as multi-managers].”

While any potential rules could carve-out a ‘safe harbour’ for pure publishing services, the UVS paper says most index providers now create products that deviate from simple benchmark-tracking.

“The point is that index providers are engaged in stock selection on behalf of clients, a defining characteristic of investment advice,” the report says. “One hallmark of the regulation of investment advisers is fiduciary duties and the concomitant avoidance or disclosure of conflicting interests.”

Furthermore, the paper notes the emergence of “single purpose” index products that could allow active managers to hide from tougher regulations behind a passive veil.

“These indices blur the distinction between passive management and active stock selection. The provider constructs an index with the objective of outperforming some other, typically broader, index,” the report says.

“… the differences between funds labeled index funds and those labeled actively-managed funds are a matter of degree, not kind, with substantial diversity within each category. Some actively-managed funds are ‘closet indexers,’ while some index funds are closet active managers.”

If adopted, the Mahoney and Robertson proposal would see most index providers subject to scrutiny by the US regulator, the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC).

Regulation would enable investors to compare the “cost of stock selection” between passive and active funds on an “apples-to-apples” basis, shed light on index security selection processes and require providers to manage conflict of interests.

“It might have been reasonable to leave the matter unresolved when indexing was in its infancy and index funds tracked only well-known general indices,” the paper says. “Those things are no longer true. The SEC should bring clarity to a multi-trillion-dollar segment of the retail investment market.”

Index providers already face some regulation in the European Union, the report says, covering registration and conflict of interest compliance duties.

Last year the number of global investment benchmarks climbed about 3 per cent to reach more than 3 million, according to the Index Industry Association annual survey of the sector.

 

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
Twitter0
LinkedIn0
Google+0
Facebook0

Read More » Investment News

Recent articles

  • Chief exits Kiwi Wealth; Mosaic names ASB ops expert as partner; T Rowe Price keeps Australasia wholesale role in the family February 28, 2021
  • Revenge against the ombudspeople: complaints body zombie legal action walks on February 28, 2021
  • Simplicity into top 10 ESG fund share for Australasia… February 28, 2021
  • … as Milford, Hyperion top Morningstar awards February 28, 2021
  • Tough calls ahead for local fixed income managers February 28, 2021
  • Boutique buoyancy management: how Ark stays afloat with more on board February 28, 2021
  • Master trusts surpass $8bn ahead of AMP passive rebirth February 28, 2021
  • T+1 and counting: why US trading systems could reach unsettling speeds February 28, 2021
  • Nature calls: under-construction financial disclosure framework to go beyond climate February 28, 2021
Finished reading? Why not subscribe? To receive a weekly email enter your email address here.

Primary Sidebar

WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Sign up here to receive our weekly newsletter.
Learn More »

Investment News

  • Chief exits Kiwi Wealth; Mosaic names ASB ops expert as partner; T Rowe Price keeps Australasia wholesale role in the family February 28, 2021
  • Revenge against the ombudspeople: complaints body zombie legal action walks on February 28, 2021
  • Simplicity into top 10 ESG fund share for Australasia… February 28, 2021
  • … as Milford, Hyperion top Morningstar awards February 28, 2021
  • Tough calls ahead for local fixed income managers February 28, 2021
  • Boutique buoyancy management: how Ark stays afloat with more on board February 28, 2021
  • Master trusts surpass $8bn ahead of AMP passive rebirth February 28, 2021
  • T+1 and counting: why US trading systems could reach unsettling speeds February 28, 2021
  • Nature calls: under-construction financial disclosure framework to go beyond climate February 28, 2021
  • Front-to-back outsourcing transforms funds management February 28, 2021

Search by Keyword

Most Recent Investment News

Chief exits Kiwi Wealth; Mosaic names ASB ops expert as partner; T Rowe Price keeps Australasia wholesale role in the family

February 28, 2021

Revenge against the ombudspeople: complaints body zombie legal action walks on

February 28, 2021

Simplicity into top 10 ESG fund share for Australasia…

February 28, 2021

… as Milford, Hyperion top Morningstar awards

February 28, 2021

Tough calls ahead for local fixed income managers

February 28, 2021

Investment News Archive

Most Popular Articles

  • NZ share-trading splurge could trigger tax alarms… posted on October 5, 2020
  • Westpac NZ flags retail advice sale to Forsyth Barr posted on October 19, 2020
  • Flint set to spark platform competition posted on August 17, 2020
  • The horror year in technicolour: free KiwiSaver 13 report released posted on September 30, 2020
  • Four to the core: Smartshares to expand, rearrange and reprice ETFs posted on June 22, 2020
  • Kitset KiwiSaver scheme set to unwrap in spring posted on April 27, 2020
  • NZ Funds directors back on board posted on April 24, 2016
  • Funds eye bargains, self-shoppers hoard cash, KiwiSavers turn conservative posted on March 15, 2020

Sponosored Content

David-Boyle

Jumping lessons: what all investors can learn from GameStop loss

What do ‘Kiwi’ experts see for 2021?

David-Boyle

On the industry play-list: four chart-topping regulations for 2021

David-Boyle

Charge of the lite (advice) brigade

Quick-links to Popular News

  • FAP Compliance
  • Coronavirus
  • New Appointments
  • Financial Markets Authority (FMA)
  • Kiwisaver
  • Climate Change
  • Crypto Currency
  • Blockchain
  • Insurance

Secondary Sidebar

Recent News

  • Chief exits Kiwi Wealth; Mosaic names ASB ops expert as partner; T Rowe Price keeps Australasia wholesale role in the family February 28, 2021
  • Revenge against the ombudspeople: complaints body zombie legal action walks on February 28, 2021
  • Simplicity into top 10 ESG fund share for Australasia… February 28, 2021
  • … as Milford, Hyperion top Morningstar awards February 28, 2021
  • Tough calls ahead for local fixed income managers February 28, 2021
  • Boutique buoyancy management: how Ark stays afloat with more on board February 28, 2021
  • Master trusts surpass $8bn ahead of AMP passive rebirth February 28, 2021
  • T+1 and counting: why US trading systems could reach unsettling speeds February 28, 2021
  • Nature calls: under-construction financial disclosure framework to go beyond climate February 28, 2021
  • Front-to-back outsourcing transforms funds management February 28, 2021

Footer

Copyright ©2020 InvestmentNews.co.nz — All Rights Reserved ·— Terms & Conditions