• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Subscribe
  • Twitter
  • RSS Feed

Investment News NZ

Investment News provides financial advisers news stories from the financial industry in New Zealand. Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter.

  • Home
  • News
  • Kiwisaver
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Investment News / Study finds dirty data the big ESG turn-off

Study finds dirty data the big ESG turn-off

November 18, 2019

Ben Colton: SSGA head of asset stewardship AOAC

Shoddy data is the single-biggest stumbling block to a wider adoption of environmental, social and governance (ESG) strategies among institutional investors, a new study by State Street Global Advisors (SSGA) has revealed.

The SSGA survey found that for “nearly half of respondents, the current state of ESG data — single sourced, low correlation and confusing terminology — is a hindering factor to accurately assessing the credentials of underlying companies and their portfolio-level impact”.

(ESG data reliability was, however, less of a concern for Asia-Pacific investors who ranked the factor seventh out of nine, well behind their chief worry – costs and resource limitations.)

According to the SSGA report, the bespoke research and scoring methodologies of the many ESG data suppliers has left many investors bewildered. In a separate study of some 30 ESG research vendors, SSGA found little correlation between the ratings of the same underlying companies by different providers.

For example, the SSGA analysis of two largest ESG data suppliers – Sustainalytics and MSCI – “determined a correlation of only 0.53 among their scores, meaning that their ratings of companies are only consistent for about half of the coverage universe”.

The result has particular implications for index investors who remain hostage to the biases of their chosen ESG researcher “in terms of data acquisition, materiality, aggregation and weighting”, the study says.

“Institutions that have implemented ESG for index-based strategies (for equities and fixed income) are most concerned about the consistency of ESG data from different providers — inconsistent ESG scoring approaches between data providers creates challenges for such investors as they try to target and track certain outcomes from their ESG investments,” the SSGA report says.

However, active investors are most concerned about the quality of ESG data compared to traditional research.

“Well over half (63%) of index investors are most reliant on the main ratings agencies,” the study says. “This is in stark contrast to active investors, at 39%. In fact, 47% of active investors rely on in-house research (versus only 26% of index investors).”

Aside from data disappointments, respondents ranked poor resources/high costs, lack of expertise and a conflict with fiduciary duty as the main ‘pull’ factors restraining ESG growth.

Curiously, the study also found – in almost equal proportions – that fiduciary duty was one of the major factors pushing investors towards ESG.

“It seems for some there’s a lingering concern that ESG adoption may hinder the ability to maximize returns,” the SSGA report says. “Despite this, there does seem to be a clear trajectory towards ESG increasingly being considered a key part of fiduciary duty.”

As well as fiduciary duty, growing regulatory pressure and risk mitigation are driving ESG adoption, the SSGA study says.

Ben Colton, SSGA head of asset stewardship APAC, said in a release: “The research results confirm what we’re hearing from our clients.

“The regulatory environment is clearly driving institutional investors towards a sea-change in ESG practices. Over the past year most of our clients have explored what they can do about their portfolios’ carbon profiles and climate-related risks.”

But the survey found most investors don’t rate ESG for its performance-enhancing qualities… yet.

“Investors aren’t primarily motivated by a view that ESG will drive outperformance, perhaps since evidence is limited at this stage given the challenges of attributing performance to ESG factors,” the report says. “And, some ESG pay-offs will be realized long term.”

The SSGA study says despite a number of pull factors dragging on ESG adoption, the push power is driving overall growth in the approach. Since a similar SSGA survey two years ago, funds managed to ESG principles grew by about a third, the report says, to top US$30 trillion, equating to “over a quarter of the world’s professionally managed assets”.

“As institutions try to respond to these competing forces — without compromising their risk–return requirements — they must chart their own course,” the paper says. “This means finding a best-fit approach to incorporating ESG factors into their investment process and balancing cost pressures with the need to build up specialist knowledge.”

The SSGA report – titled ‘Into the mainstream: ESG at the tipping point’ – surveyed more than 300 large institutional investors across the globe covering “private and public pension funds, endowments, foundations and official institutions”.

 

Twitter0
LinkedIn0
Google+0
Facebook0

Read More » Investment News

Recent articles

  • On the industry play-list: four chart-topping regulations for 2021 January 15, 2021
  • ASB investment veteran among five Jarden hires; van Schaardenberg exits Findex January 10, 2021
  • Wholesale disclosure loophole for $750k under question January 10, 2021
  • Bear marks time for last dance as bubble-pop music sounds January 10, 2021
  • UK competition regulator gaffe keeps GBST in play for FNZ January 10, 2021
  • Russell positive on climate change but negative screening could be a no-no January 10, 2021
  • How the world’s biggest funds coped in 2020; NZ Super tops five-year figures January 10, 2021
  • Managers tipped to double tech spend by 2030 January 10, 2021
  • S&P results highlight nine-year run for NZX; value peeks through as 2020 ends January 10, 2021

Primary Sidebar

WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Sign up here to receive our weekly newsletter.
Learn More »

Most Recent Investment News

David-Boyle

On the industry play-list: four chart-topping regulations for 2021

January 15, 2021

ASB investment veteran among five Jarden hires; van Schaardenberg exits Findex

January 10, 2021

Wholesale disclosure loophole for $750k under question

January 10, 2021

Bear marks time for last dance as bubble-pop music sounds

January 10, 2021

UK competition regulator gaffe keeps GBST in play for FNZ

January 10, 2021

Search by Keyword

Investment News

  • On the industry play-list: four chart-topping regulations for 2021 January 15, 2021
  • ASB investment veteran among five Jarden hires; van Schaardenberg exits Findex January 10, 2021
  • Wholesale disclosure loophole for $750k under question January 10, 2021
  • Bear marks time for last dance as bubble-pop music sounds January 10, 2021
  • UK competition regulator gaffe keeps GBST in play for FNZ January 10, 2021
  • Russell positive on climate change but negative screening could be a no-no January 10, 2021
  • How the world’s biggest funds coped in 2020; NZ Super tops five-year figures January 10, 2021
  • Managers tipped to double tech spend by 2030 January 10, 2021
  • S&P results highlight nine-year run for NZX; value peeks through as 2020 ends January 10, 2021
  • Why 2021 shapes as a big year for governance activism January 10, 2021

Investment News Archive

Most Popular Articles

  • Westpac NZ flags retail advice sale to Forsyth Barr posted on October 19, 2020
  • The horror year in technicolour: free KiwiSaver 13 report released posted on September 30, 2020
  • Flint set to spark platform competition posted on August 17, 2020
  • NZ share-trading splurge could trigger tax alarms… posted on October 5, 2020
  • Four to the core: Smartshares to expand, rearrange and reprice ETFs posted on June 22, 2020
  • Kitset KiwiSaver scheme set to unwrap in spring posted on April 27, 2020
  • Funds eye bargains, self-shoppers hoard cash, KiwiSavers turn conservative posted on March 15, 2020
  • AMP Capital NZ chief quits amid equities exodus offshore posted on August 28, 2020

Sponosored Content

David-Boyle

On the industry play-list: four chart-topping regulations for 2021

David-Boyle

Charge of the lite (advice) brigade

Nathan Field

Pandemic Baby Boom a Bust

Star-date 2020: it’s inflation Jim but not as we know it

Quick-links to Popular News

  • FAP Compliance
  • Coronavirus
  • New Appointments
  • Financial Markets Authority (FMA)
  • Kiwisaver
  • Climate Change
  • Crypto Currency
  • Blockchain
  • Insurance

Secondary Sidebar

Recent News

  • On the industry play-list: four chart-topping regulations for 2021 January 15, 2021
  • ASB investment veteran among five Jarden hires; van Schaardenberg exits Findex January 10, 2021
  • Wholesale disclosure loophole for $750k under question January 10, 2021
  • Bear marks time for last dance as bubble-pop music sounds January 10, 2021
  • UK competition regulator gaffe keeps GBST in play for FNZ January 10, 2021
  • Russell positive on climate change but negative screening could be a no-no January 10, 2021
  • How the world’s biggest funds coped in 2020; NZ Super tops five-year figures January 10, 2021
  • Managers tipped to double tech spend by 2030 January 10, 2021
  • S&P results highlight nine-year run for NZX; value peeks through as 2020 ends January 10, 2021
  • Why 2021 shapes as a big year for governance activism January 10, 2021

Footer

Copyright ©2020 InvestmentNews.co.nz — All Rights Reserved ·— Terms & Conditions