• Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to secondary sidebar
  • Skip to footer
  • Subscribe
  • Twitter
  • RSS Feed

Investment News NZ

Investment News provides financial advisers news stories from the financial industry in New Zealand. Subscribe to our free weekly newsletter.

  • Home
  • News
  • Kiwisaver
  • Subscribe
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Contact
You are here: Home / Investment News / How ESG ratings providers let the side down

How ESG ratings providers let the side down

February 16, 2020

Feifei Li: Research Affiliates head of investment strategy

An often-expressed criticism of the ESG investing space, mainly by institutional investors, is the lack of robust benchmarks and/or ratings from independent bodies. ESG investing is complex. A new study by Research Affiliates indicates just how much work the industry needs to do to improve accountability.

The study by Dr Feifi Li and fellow researcher Ari Polychronopoulos, argues that the deficiency with ESG ratings is actually hindering the adoption of those investment strategies more broadly.

Research Affiliates, the California-based investment and research firm, which first promoted the idea of smart-beta strategies with its fundamental, ‘RAFI’, index, concentrates on efficiencies in investment management. The study is called: “What a Difference an ESG Ratings Provider Makes”. It analyses the work of two major ESG ratings firms in the US, against a backdrop of other ESG information providers. Their differences are significant and worrying. The study identified and looked at about 70 ESG ratings providers. The key points are:

. ESG ratings vary markedly by ESG ratings provider because each provider has a unique methodology for assigning company-specific ratings. Investors, therefore, must ensure the approach taken by the ratings provider they rely on is consistent with their ESG preferences or they risk constructing portfolios that do not align with their ESG views.

. ESG portfolios constructed using the ratings of two well-known ESG ratings providers yield large performance dispersion and low correlation of returns. The differences are even greater at the individual ratings level for environmental, social, and governance scores.

. The differences in how ratings providers calculate ESG scores can result in the same company being ranked quite highly by one provider and quite poorly by another. Understanding which metrics are evaluated and how they are assessed is essential to investors selecting stocks that meet the ESG criteria they care about.

The authors note that ESG is a ‘highly heterogenous’ space. Investors, asset managers and ESG ratings firms each have their own preferences about what issues are important and how they should be addressed. The two ‘well-known’ ESG ratings providers analysed closely by the authors are not named in the report.

The subtext, though, is that neither are up to scratch for a new ESG benchmarking system to be used by a big fiduciary fund. Research Affiliates is a lot kinder than that, saying that the different methodologies reflect different values and points of view. As ESG continues to grow in importance, it seems it times for the research part of the funds management industry to get its act together.

 

Greg Bright is publisher of Investor Strategy News (Australia)

Read More » Investment News

Recent articles

  • KiwiSaver comes out mixed in budget wash May 25, 2025
  • FMA wins $6.7m pay rise on compliance, enforcement upgrades May 25, 2025
  • Amplifi names new CEO; Fisher CFO quits; Alvarium fills CIO gap May 25, 2025
  • NZX investment platform wins more advice clients; FNZ court date looms   May 25, 2025
  • New direction: where the NZ financial advice industry needs to go next May 25, 2025
  • Portfolio in a storm: why global listed infrastructure is taking off May 25, 2025
  • Regulator lines up mass exemptions for review May 25, 2025
  • Wanted: IOSCO calls for clean-up in digital fin-town May 25, 2025
  • Calming influences May 25, 2025
Finished reading? Why not subscribe? To receive a weekly email enter your email address here.

Primary Sidebar

WEEKLY NEWSLETTER

Sign up here to receive our weekly newsletter.
Learn More »

Most Recent Investment News

KiwiSaver comes out mixed in budget wash

May 25, 2025

FMA wins $6.7m pay rise on compliance, enforcement upgrades

May 25, 2025

Mint chief executive, Rebecca Thomas

Amplifi names new CEO; Fisher CFO quits; Alvarium fills CIO gap

May 25, 2025

NZX investment platform wins more advice clients; FNZ court date looms  

May 25, 2025

New direction: where the NZ financial advice industry needs to go next

May 25, 2025

Search by Keyword

INVESTMENT NEWS

  • KiwiSaver comes out mixed in budget wash May 25, 2025
  • FMA wins $6.7m pay rise on compliance, enforcement upgrades May 25, 2025
  • Amplifi names new CEO; Fisher CFO quits; Alvarium fills CIO gap May 25, 2025
  • NZX investment platform wins more advice clients; FNZ court date looms   May 25, 2025
  • New direction: where the NZ financial advice industry needs to go next May 25, 2025
  • Portfolio in a storm: why global listed infrastructure is taking off May 25, 2025
  • Regulator lines up mass exemptions for review May 25, 2025

Quick-links to Popular News

  • FAP Compliance
  • Coronavirus
  • New Appointments
  • Financial Markets Authority (FMA)
  • Kiwisaver
  • Climate Change
  • Crypto Currency
  • Blockchain
  • Insurance

Sponsored Content

Calming influences

Trade walls, profit falls: NZX 50’s tariff exposure unpacked

Building a smarter portfolio: strategies for diversified growth 

Five strategies for dealing with market volatility

Unlocking the potential of smarter portfolio management for New Zealand’s largest investors

Bullish on bullion? Discover gold’s role as a diversifier

More Sponsored Posts >>>

Secondary Sidebar

Recent News

  • KiwiSaver comes out mixed in budget wash May 25, 2025
  • FMA wins $6.7m pay rise on compliance, enforcement upgrades May 25, 2025
  • Amplifi names new CEO; Fisher CFO quits; Alvarium fills CIO gap May 25, 2025
  • NZX investment platform wins more advice clients; FNZ court date looms   May 25, 2025
  • New direction: where the NZ financial advice industry needs to go next May 25, 2025
  • Portfolio in a storm: why global listed infrastructure is taking off May 25, 2025
  • Regulator lines up mass exemptions for review May 25, 2025
  • Wanted: IOSCO calls for clean-up in digital fin-town May 25, 2025
  • Calming influences May 25, 2025
  • Consilium sells to FirstCape May 19, 2025

Footer

Copyright ©2025 InvestmentNews.co.nz — All Rights Reserved — Terms & Conditions